
by Dr. Sandy Yang
Listening to villain Baron Scarpia’s velvety baritone in a flawless bel canto performance of Puccini’s Tosca, I found it hard to imagine the evil intent behind every word. Can evil coinhere with goodness and beauty? I wondered. Or is beauty, as they say, “only skin deep”? Such reflections arose from an encounter with Scarpia for students and faculty in Cedarville’s Department of Music and Worship at an April 21st, 2024, Dayton Opera production of Giacomo Puccini’s opera Tosca.
Scarpia joins the ranks of only a few dramatic characters I can recall that are so purely evil that they have no apparent redeeming qualities–Shakespeare’s Richard III and Iago are others that come to mind. Puccini’s Scarpia is a chief of police who finds delight in abusing his position for brutal personal retaliation and amorous conquests. In the titular role, tragic heroine Floria Tosca watches helplessly as Scarpia orders her lover, Mario Cavaradossi, to be hauled off to prison, likely to be executed for a crime he did not commit. With this obstacle removed, Scarpia then attempts to conquer Tosca. When she resists, he agrees to release Cavaradossi in exchange for a moment alone with her. While Scarpia writes a letter feigning Cavaradossi’s release, Tosca notices a knife on Scarpia’s dinner cart. She hides the knife in the folds of her dress and approaches him. Delighted by her seeming turn of heart, he reaches out, only to be met with a blade that pierces his heart. Within less than a minute, Scarpia will be dead–but in operatic form, he delivers his dying lines in stunning bel canto.
Whether he is at this moment of death deceptive or merely expressing universal human pathos, Scarpia’s performance is nothing short of what I would call beautiful. But what a disparity there is between this beauty and his evil nature!
Or is there? Ruminations on Puccini’s portrayal of Scarpia led me to some insightful conversations with colleagues and to the source of truth, Scripture.
The term beauty in Scripture and theology is most often used to characterize things in the physical realm that are to be desired–such as bel canto singing. In the pre-Reformation text Summa theologica, Thomas Aquinas designates beauty as that which possesses integrity, proportion (or harmony), and clarity (light or color)–all of which Aquinas identifies with the Son of God Himself. Yet the term is rarely used in Scripture to describe God. Isaiah 53:2 emphasizes this disjunction (and the association of beauty with desire) in describing the coming Christ: “He has no. . .beautiful appearance that we should desire Him.”
The beautiful may share with the good the trait of desirability, but beauty is not necessarily the opposite of evil. The more appropriate contrast with evil is, of course, goodness. Good is used many times in Scripture to describe God and His creation; Genesis 1 repeatedly refers to God’s creation as “good” and then “very good”; King David enjoins readers in Psalm 34:8, “Oh, taste and see that the LORD is good!” (cf. also 1 Pet. 2:3). And good and evil are of course repeatedly opposed, as for instance in Leviticus 5:4 (“to do evil or to do good”) and I Kings 3:9 (“discern between good and evil”).
My original speculation was that beauty and goodness must coinhere if beauty is truly beautiful and good is truly good. But I was unable to find a verse of Scripture that brought goodness and beauty together in that way. In fact, apparent beauty may well mask moral evil in our fallen world; Satan “transfigures himself into an angel of light” (2 Cor. 11:14). And as in Isaiah 53:2, goodness may conversely be cloaked.
The Scriptural acknowledgement of discrepancy between beauty and goodness might prompt us to consider the artform of opera on parallel planes. On the plane of the drama, Scarpia is pure evil; he has no goodness, not even one bit. On the plane of the music, Puccini’s score is gorgeous, and we would name it both beautiful and good—for all the characters, including Scarpia. Only those performers who can deliver a good and beautiful performance can be legitimate contributors on opera’s musical plane and participants in the artform.
The disparity between beauty and goodness that is so glaring in Puccini’s Scarpia may be a helpful case for Christians engaging with the arts. In it we recognize that while there may be a plane of an artistic work that we rightly desire for its beauty, there may be another level of corruption, perhaps much more subtle than that of Tosca, that we must discern and resist. As Christians growing in our appreciation of the arts, may we all develop maturity in allowing the Word of God to dwell richly in us, that it may do its work to “discern the thoughts and intents of the heart” (Heb. 4:12)–even those portrayed in art.
Posted in: Arts & Humanities, Music and Worship